Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Sustainable Agriculture: The Right Choice!

Do the benefits of relying on a few highly productive livestock breeds and crop varieties outweigh the risks of reducing genetic diversity by allowing less productive breeds to become extinct? That is the question. FAO’S Global Databank for Animal Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture noted that about 20 percent of the 7,616 breeds documented in their research are considered to be under threat of extinction (1). The destruction of this diversity is mainly due to the rapid spread of animal production caused by the high demands for beef, chicken, pork and other livestock products. This will only increase as the worlds population rises as a predicted 6.2 billion people today to a staggering 9 billion people in the next 40 years (2).

Black and white Holstein-Friesian cow
Our demand for highly productive breeds such as black and white Holstein-Friesian cows has caused a drastic drop in the numbers of other breeds of cows such as the Ankole cattle found in Uganda (2). Another example of this is in Kenya due to the introduction of the Dorper sheep the pure-bred Red Maasai sheep has almost completely disappeared (2). A lot of the breeds currently at risk have disease resistance genes that the highly productive livestock breeds we use today don’t have. If this diversity were to disappear many diseases could be created and many species would die off because they wouldn’t be able to fight it. There are two different forms of agriculture: Industrial Agriculture and Sustainable Agriculture.




Industrial agriculture can include both animal production on a large scale but crops as well. They would take one crop and then grow it on hundreds of acres of land (3). Chemical fertilizers are then used to add nutrients back into the crops and pesticides are sprayed to remove insects. This requires heavy machinery and the burning of fossil fuels which leads to the destruction of our environment. Animals are also placed in confined and overcrowded conditions in which their bodies can be genetically modified so that they can fit more animals into the sheds and prevent them from their natural behaviors. Antibiotics and hormones are given to help the animals grow faster and bigger (3).




Sustainable agriculture is a way of raising food that is healthy for both the animals, consumers and the environment (4). These types of farms raise different types of animals and crops to help ensure biodiversity and prevent any diseases. The animals are allowed to carry out with their natural behaviors and are fed a proper diet for their species. Sustainable agriculture is much better for the environment as well because they do not use any pesticides or fertilizers. Any waste that is created inside the farm stays within the farm’s ecosystem and is then re-used (4).

Although industrial agriculture sounds easier, is it really? Is it easier harming the biodiversity of our planet just to produce livestock and crops on a large scale basis? To me, Sustainable Agriculture is the right choice and can keep up with the rapid growth of the global human population. Knowing your food was grown in a clean and humane way is very reassuring to anyone. Biodiversity is what the human life depends on and if we continue with our ways will our demise soon follow?

Work Cited:
1.) Practicial Steps to Preserve Barnyard Diversity: CGIAR, September 2007
2.) Farm Animal Diversity Under Threat: Beurkle, Teresa, June 2007 http://www.fao.org/newsroom/en/news/2007/1000598/index.html
3.) Factory Farming and Industrial Agriculture: April 3, 2009 http://www.sustainabletable.org/2009/04/factory-farming/
4.) What is Sustainable Agriculture? April 3, 2009
5.) Life on Earth- The Importance of Biodiversity: April 10, 2010 http://youthink.worldbank.org/issues/environment/life-earth-importance-biodiversity

Blogs Commented On:

7 comments:

  1. Great blog Nicole; I really enjoyed reading it. I liked how you started your blog off with a startling fact which was that 20% of the 7616 breeds documented are under threat of extinction. I never thought about the high demand for specific live stocks such as chicken and pork. I liked how you mentioned how disease prone the highly productive livestock breeds are. You did a great job talking about industrial agriculture in regards to the animal issue. The animals from industrial agriculture are breed in unsanitary conditions and can be harmful to a person’s health. I also found it horrific when you said antibiotics and hormones are given to help the animal grow faster and bigger. Are we really digesting these animals which have been chemically modified? In addition, I think that the livestock in the industrial agriculture can be described as animal cruelty. From seeing the images your blog contains, I believe that there should be regulations that restrict farms from abusing their animals such as the industrial agricultural farms. I agree with you that sustainable agriculture is the best farming method because it is good for the environment and is healthy for you to eat. Your blog was very informative and well organized, excellent work!
    -Caitlin

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nicole this blog was one of the best I've read! It was really shocking,informative and helpful. I like how your focus was on the loss of biodiversity because I haven't read any blogs that are of this focus.

    I can't believe that 20% of the 7616 breeds are under the threat of extinction, it is clearly human behaviour that is prompting this. We need to realize the long term affects our behaviour has! It's scary how we let an entire species almost completely disappear (red Maasai Sheep) just for our own personal gain.

    The facts you provided for both industrial and sustainable agriculture were clear and very good. You really described the process behind industrial farming and not only how it uses pesticides and animal cruelty but also because it's heavy use of machinery it releases a ton of fossil fuels into the environment.

    Your blog was fantastic and I liked your visuals too.
    Great Job!
    Natasha

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nicole, I really liked your blog, it was very informative and enjoyable to read. The fact that 20% of breeds are extinct just astonishes me, and I never would have known that if I hadn't of read your blog. I liked how you compared the two types of agricultural farming after presenting valid facts for both sides. Your blog was very good!
    Rachael

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great Job Nicole. You're blog provided me, and I'm sure anyone else who read it with insightful and informative information, that if they didn't know these things before, they will have an opinion on them now. Like me, for instance. I never really realized where and how the food I am eating has been prepared. I have a completely new outlook on the two different sides of farming and understand how important it is to use sustainable farming instead. I really liked how you incorporated ideas about biodiversity into your blog and mentioned your opinion, because i believe many people feel the same way you do, like myself. It's one of those things you don't really think about often because food and eating is a part of life. We don't really realize where it comes from. Thank you for the insight in this topic, it really opened my eyes about agriculture. :)
    Great Job again!
    Taylor

    ReplyDelete
  5. oh my gosh, awesome blog Nicole. I like how you were so specific with your examples for industrial agriculture. I can't believe they do all that to our food, it really gets you thinking about what your eating whether it's a burger at a fast food restaurant or a home cooked meal. I totally agree, sustainable agriculture is the way to go because of the environment and human health. Good job!

    Liam D.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi,Nicole,
    I was amazed by the fact that 20% of 7616 breeds are disappearing from the Earth!This is not even a number of animals but a number of types of animals. It really makes me considering what are animals exactly. We have been treating animals like food for many years, I felt very sorry for the hens in the cages after I saw your fourth picture. Maybe sustainable agriculture is a way more slower method to produce food, but it is much more healthier!
    Great job~!

    Pauline

    ReplyDelete
  7. It's stunning to know that 20% of the 7,616 breeds are under extinction and the worse part about it is it can be avoided. All we have to do is choose sustainable agriculture over industrial agriculture. But I think it would be hard for humanity to survive on only sustainable farming because it would be hard to get as much food out to all humans of the world. Which is why industrial may just be the way of the future. As much as we may not want to accept it, we really have no choose. Great blog and information.

    ReplyDelete